Professional Responsibility Blog

Professor Alberto Bernabe - The University of Illinois-Chicago School of Law

Monday, July 27, 2009

Lawyer disbarred because he did not take his role as a juror seriously

›
The California Supreme Court has disbarred an attorney who reportedly changed his vote during jury deliberations simply to end a tie because...
Tuesday, July 21, 2009

How NOT to practice law: lie to the judge

›
Suppose the judge calls for a hearing and you are not prepared. Here is what you should NOT do: do not tell the judge you can't make it ...
Monday, July 20, 2009

Should there be a duty to report your own negligence during the representation?

›
The Legal Profession Blog is reporting today that the Minnesota Lawyers Professional Responsibility Board has proposed the adoption of Opin...
Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Trial tactics?

›
In my Professional Responsibility course, we spend a bit of time talking about "trial tactics." Here is a story that falls in tha...
Saturday, July 11, 2009

More on "Sotomayor and Associates"

›
Go here for another update.
Tuesday, July 7, 2009

One more update on the story re Judge's Sotomayor law firm name

›
Here is yet another comment on Judge Sotomayor's possibly misleading use of a firm name by Eric Turkewitz, the blogger who actually brou...

Don't take more work than you can handle

›
The New York Appellate Division for the First Judicial Department has imposed a three month suspension in a matter involving two instances o...

Update on Judge Sotomayor's Advertising issue

›
Almost a month ago, I posted a note about a story regarding Judge Sotomayor's use of the phrase "and associates" in her firm n...
Monday, July 6, 2009

Statute of limitations mistake results in disciplinary sanctions

›
Mike Frisch of the Legal Profession Blog wrote today on a case in which the Tennessee Supreme Court affirmed a five month suspension impose...
Thursday, July 2, 2009

Should a candidate be denied admission to the bar because of too much debt?

›
Should a candidate be denied admission to the bar because of too much debt? Yes, says a panel in New York. Full story here. I understand it...

More prosecutorial misconduct

›
After seeing two cases in less than three months where the Department of Justice asked the court to dismiss indictments after allegations th...

Illinois adopts ABA Model Rules

›
The Illinois Supreme Court announced yesterday it has (finally) adopted a new set of rules mostly based on the ABA Model Rules of Profession...

Prosecutor's comments result in conviction reversal and sanctions

›
The Legal Profession Blog is reporting today on yet another case of prosecutorial misconduct - improper arguments during the closing in a mu...
Thursday, June 25, 2009

Sleeping during trial = ineffective assistance of counsel

›
A Brooklyn judge has reversed a conviction because the defendant's attorney (Michael Harrison) repeatedly fell asleep at trial, allegedl...
Thursday, June 18, 2009

It's not so bad to violate a rule if you have a good reason for it. Huh??!!

›
The Legal Profession Blog is reporting today on a decision from the Maryland Court of Appeals that raises an interesting question regarding ...
Thursday, June 11, 2009

Court finds concurrent conflict does not justify reversing conviction

›
The Legal Profession Blog is reporting today that the Idaho Supreme Court has affirmed a defendant's murder conviction even though the ...

How not to practice law: lie to the disciplinary committee

›
Again, taking a break from grading exams to post this new installment to our on-going series on "how NOT to practice law." So, her...

Billing for time spent billing?

›
Suppose an attorney prepares a bill and sends it to a client. Then suppose the client asks the lawyer to review it, explain some items or re...

Illinois appellate court finds ineffective assistance of cousel

›
I am taking a break from grading exams to catch up with blogs, news and other stories. About a month ago, I reported that the Illinois Appel...
Sunday, June 7, 2009

Did Judge Sotomayor violate ethics rules when in private practice?

›
A couple of months ago, I commented on a decision of the Supreme Court of Ohio which found that a lawyer had violated a number rules of pro...
Monday, June 1, 2009

Exams and vacation

›
You may have noticed I have not been posting any news recently. I have been busy trying to finish grading final exams and tomorrow I am taki...
Saturday, May 23, 2009

Comment on crisis re access to representation

›
Tort Deform Blog has published a short comment on the crisis regarding lack of access to legal representation in civil cases. Among other th...
Monday, May 18, 2009

More on whether authors of "torture memos" should be disciplined

›
I have posted before on the debate regarding whether the drafters of the "torture memos" should be disciplined for violations of e...

More on Pres. Obama's military tribunals

›
Here is a link to a good article on Pres. Obama's decision to resume the use of Bush era military tribunals by Joanne Mariner, the Terr...
Saturday, May 16, 2009

Obama to continue use of military tribunals

›
The Obama administration has announced it will restart the controversial Bush military tribunal system. The tribunal system has been widely ...

Article on what clients should think about when discussing hourly rates

›
Here is a link to an interesting article on the debate over hourly fee rates. As the article states, "the imminent demise of the billab...
Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Illinois appellate court reverses conviction for ineffective assistance of cousel

›
In a rare victory for criminal defendants, the Chicago Daily Bulletin reports that the 5th District Appellate Court of Illinois has reverse...
Friday, May 8, 2009

Lack of funding affects representation of indigent defendants

›
I have blogged before about the problems in our criminal justice sytem due to the inadequate funding for programs that provide representati...

Are firms overbilling for online research?

›
Assume a firm has an account with an online research service like Westlaw or Lexis according to which the firm pays a flat fee for using the...
Thursday, May 7, 2009

Study Claims Bankruptcy Lawyers Are Billing Illegally

›
In a recent story published in the ABA Journal.com, Debra Cassens Weiss states that "A new study claims bankruptcy lawyers are billing ...
Thursday, April 30, 2009

What do you have to do to get disbarred in Alabama?

›
I spend some time in class looking at the disparities in sanctions imposed for different types of offenses. Inevitably, we conclude that the...
Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Disciplinary procedure confidentiality rule declared unconstitutional

›
Louisiana Supreme Court has ruled that confidentiality rule that blocks any participant in an attorney disciplinary proceeding from publicly...

Sanctions for deceptive firm name

›
Earlier this month the Supreme Court of Ohio ruled that a sole practitioner violated numerous ethics rules by using misleading firm names th...
Tuesday, April 28, 2009

Yet another case of prosecutorial misconduct

›
Not too long ago I posted some comments on recent cases involving improper arguments by prosecutors (see here and here . Also, see here fo...

Update on Supreme Court case re prosecutor immunity

›
A few days ago I posted a note on a case called Pottawattamie County v. Harrington which raises the issue of whether prosecutors should be ...

Update on the case of the lawyer who altered law school transcript

›
A few days ago I reported on the case of a lawyer who was disciplined for, among other things having altered grades in a law school transcr...
Monday, April 27, 2009

Different view on what constitutes business transaction with client

›
Model Rule 1.8 (and its state equivalents) do not ban a lawyer from engaging in business transactions with clients. However, it is clear th...
Wednesday, April 22, 2009

Another wake up call for students: conduct while in law school will come back to haunt you

›
An Illinois Hearing Board has recommended a three year suspension in a case involving an attorney who had failed to disclose information in ...
Tuesday, April 21, 2009

Should a lawyer be suspended from practice for driving too fast?

›
Here is a new case that involves the often debated issue of whether an attorney should be sanctioned for conduct not related to the practice...

How not to practice law: forge the judge's signature

›
The Legal Profession Blog is reporting today on a case out of Ohio in which a lawyer forged the signature of a judge on a draft judgment ent...

Problems with criminal justice system

›
There is a lot of literature out there criticizing our criminal justice system for, among other things, not doing enough to protect the righ...
Monday, April 20, 2009

How not to practice law: ask for stolen property as payment for your services

›
Here is another entry into our list of ways not to practice law : offer to exchange legal services for stolen property. Story here.

Supreme Court to Consider Prosecutor Immunity for Using False Testimony

›
Debra Cassens Weiss of the ABAJournal.com reports that the U.S. Supreme Court has decided to hear a case involving prosecutor immunity from ...

Two thirds of Americans support legal aid for the poor

›
Two-thirds of Americans polled by the ABA support federal funding to help Americans who need legal assistance. Story here.
Friday, April 17, 2009

NY denies admission to candidate because of failure to pay student loans.

›
A few days ago I posted about a lawyer who was disbarred for not paying student loans. Today, the ABA Journal.com is reporting that the App...
Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Illinois Opinion Adopts ABA View on Contact With Current Employees of Corporate Party

›
Illinois Rule of Professional Conduct 4.2 generally prohibits a lawyer who is representing a client from dealing directly with others who ha...

Court holds that a lawyer's ability to pay must be considered in fashioning a monetary sanction

›
I have long been a proponent that sanctions must mean something. Mere slaps on the wrist do more harm than good. See here , for example. Whe...

More training for prosecutors

›
Attorney General Eric Holder Jr. said on Tuesday he would require additional training for prosecutors to reinforce their understanding of r...

Want to get disbarred? Go rob a bank

›
Back in January I reported on the proposed disbarrment of an attorney for having engaged in bank robbery (duh!). Yesterday, the Supreme Cou...

Perry Mason Arrested For Unauthorized Practice Of Law

›
A 43 year old man going by the name Perry Mason, was arrested in Houston for practicing law without a license. Full story (very short) here...
Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Lawyer disbarred for failing to pay student loans

›
Here is another wake up call for our students: pay your loans! The National Law Journal is reporting today that the Texas Court of Appeals ...
Monday, April 13, 2009

New report on prosecutorial misconduct

›
The Justice Project has released a report on prosecutorial misconduct. The report is available here. It starts: "Prosecutors are argua...

Another example of how not to practice law: be rude to the judge's clerk

›
The ABA Journal.com is reporting today that the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld the punishment barring lawyer...

Possible changes to admission (and readmission) rules in Florida

›
The ABA Journal.com is reporting today that a report by a group reviewing Florida bar admission standards has called for a number of changes...
Saturday, April 11, 2009

Update on problems with the new Model Rule 1.10

›
About a month ago, I posted a note on the fact that the ABA made a pretty major mistake in drafting the recently approved amendment to Mode...

Another example of how not to practice law: don't proofread anything before you file it in court

›
Irked by a Wisconsin lawyer's failure to proofread his pleadings, among other errors, a state appeals court has suggested that the lawye...

Federal prosecutorial misconduct

›
In a strongly worded, 50-page opinion (available here ), U.S. District Judge Alan S. Gold has reprimanded federal prosecutors and ordered th...
Tuesday, April 7, 2009

When should the judge take action regarding prosecutorial comments?

›
The North Carolina Court of Appeals recently affirmed a criminal conviction in a murder case, rejecting the contention that the trial judge...

New York City Public Defenders’ Caseloads to Be Capped

›
A provision in New York’s $131 billion state budget bill passed last week calls for a cap on the number of criminal cases each New York City...

Two N.J. Judges Face Ethics Charges Over Derogatory Comments From Bench

›
Two New Jersey trial judges are in hot water for belittling litigants with discourteous, undignified and discriminatory remarks from the ben...

Supreme Court to consider whether fees can be enhanced based on quality of representation

›
On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to consider whether a fee awarded under a federal fee-shifting statute can ever be enhanced based s...

More prosecutorial misconduct alleged

›
The Justice Department is once again being threatened with contempt of court after United States District Court Judge Emmet Sullivan found t...
Monday, April 6, 2009

Prosecutorial misconduct; limits of proper argument

›
There appears to be an emerging trend of bar prosecutions against prosecutors -- which is definitely a good thing, by the way. Here is ano...
Friday, April 3, 2009

On the relation between the rules of professional conduct and the concept of duty

›
Most states' rules of professional conduct state that they are not meant to illustrate duties in tort law, but that many (perhaps most) ...

Ineffective assistance of counsel in criminal cases

›
Here is a link to a comment by Prof. Monroe Freedman on the appalling situation of ineffective assistance of counsel that so many indigent ...
Thursday, April 2, 2009

Consumer agency sues over Florida's rules on advertising

›
Public Citizen, a national consumer advocacy agency, has filed a lawsuit against The Florida Bar challenging the constitutionality of its ba...

Attorney ordered to return fees for violation of court order

›
A couple of months ago I posted a note about a case where, after a judge ordered a lawyer off a case and banned from getting any fees (beca...

Article about in house counsel conviction

›
Here is a link to an article that discusses the indictment, trial, conviction, and sentencing of Berkeley Nutraceuticals’ former in-house co...
Wednesday, April 1, 2009

BNA Lawyers' Manual article on Candor to the Tribunal

›
The most recent ABA/BNA Lawyers' Manual on Professional Responsibility has a good article summarizing the state of the law related to an...

‘Reverse’ Contingent Fees Are Allowed in DC

›
The District of Columbia bar's ethics committee issued an opinion this month that concludes that attorneys may charge a reverse continge...
Tuesday, March 31, 2009

Attorney who became prominent for provocative ad campaign and nude photos is now suing Playboy

›
Way back when I started this blog, I posted a photo that started a big controversy over advertising in Chicago. It depicted the semi nude bo...

No duty to referring attorney

›
Here is an interesting case that discusses an issue I had never seen before.An attorney, representing a plaintiff in a medical malpractice a...

Judge disqualified after sharp exchange with attorney

›
Prof. Jonathan Turley reports today about a case in which the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals which removed Judge Dean Whipple of the Wester...

Should we judge attorneys based on their clients?

›
What are the moral implications of representation? Is it fair to judge attorneys based on their clients? These are important questions that ...

Lawyer Tirades costs client $15 million

›
I have recently posted a couple of comments on cases that discuss the limits of proper argument ( here and here ). Here is another new cas...
Monday, March 30, 2009

Billing during tough financial times

›
Here is a link to an article in the National Law Journal about billing clients during tough financial times. Full story here.
Saturday, March 28, 2009

Illinois slaps on the wrist for stealing. Bad example!

›
The Legal Profession Blog reports today that an Illinois hearing board concluded that a lawyer's license should be "monitored rathe...

Judges involved in juvenile court fraud

›
A couple of days ago I posted a note about a case in Michigan involving a judge and prosecutor who got caught in a scheme to allow perjured ...
Friday, March 27, 2009

Congress Raises Fee for Federal Court Assigned Counsel

›
Marcia Coyle, of the New York Law Journal, is reporting today that Congress has authorizeda raise for attorneys who accept assignments under...

Senators introduce bill to increase Legal Services funding and to lift restrictions

›
Law.com is reporting today that a key group of Democratic senators has introduced a bill to increase funding for the Legal Services Corp. (L...
Thursday, March 26, 2009

Judge & Prosecutor Indicted Over Perjury

›
A Michigan judge, a former prosecutor and two police officers have been charged with several counts of misconduct and conspiracy to commit p...
Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Supreme Court decides case re ineffective assistance of counsel

›
In an opinion announced yesterday, the U.S. Supreme Court rejected a claim of innefective assistance of counsel filed by an inmate convicted...
Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Attempt to rescue IOLTA plan during bad economy

›
As all other states, Illinios has an IOLTA program which uses the interest earned in certain lawyer trust bank accounts to fund legal aid pr...

Ineffective assistance of counsel in death penalty cases

›
A recent study of capital cases in Texas shows that nine death row inmates lost their appeals due to the failure of counsel to file by the c...
Monday, March 23, 2009

Attorney client privilege over threats to others?

›
Suppose a client confidentially tells his attorney that he is going to kill a certain person and that the attorney then discloses the inform...
‹
›
Home
View web version
Professor Alberto Bernabe
UIC School of Law, Chicago
View my complete profile
Powered by Blogger.